Imagine a four-bedroom home; with two and half baths and around 2200 sq. ft. of living area. This is the criteria Coldwell Banker used for its latest survey of homes. Every year Coldwell Banker studies the prices of homes in Canada, the U.S. and Puerto Rico, and a sampling of 56 countries/territories outside of North America where Coldwell Banker Real Estate has a presence. The Coldwell Banker Home Price Comparison Index (HPCI) is a major marketing tool for us, as its findings are published throughout the world in a whole range of magazines trade journals and other studies. It really focuses the attention on how the same house can have such a varied value attached to it, just by moving cities. Obviously, if you move a house to an Asian city, where the norm is apartments, the price of the house will be very expensive. The same house in Latin America will be considerably cheaper because the construction style changes. Frost is not an issue, and a house can be built simply from concrete and rebar.
This particular house used in the study is one that we would call an executive home. This type of house a middle-management corporate employee would live with their spouse and children, and maybe a maid or another generation of the family. According to the survey this type of house is quite a bargain here in Canada. But the study’s most interesting conclusion is that there is a price gap of more than two million dollars between the most expensive and most affordable North American markets for that same home.
In the annual comparison of similar homes in 345 North American markets, La Jolla, CA led the list as the most expensive real estate market on the continent with an average home price of $2,125,000 US. Vancouver, BC placed tenth on the North American most expensive list at $1,174,241 US ($1,262,625 CDN) topping the 35 Canadian markets studied. Grayling, Michigan was North America’s most affordable market, one of 20 similarly priced communities on the most affordable list. Canada’s most affordable major market Charlottetown, PEI was narrowly edged out of the North American top ten most affordable markets. A similarly sized home there costs only $147,560 US ($158,667 CDN).
Internationally, Singapore, $1.9 million US dollars, was the most expensive market for the same type of home compared with Salinas, Ecuador, $69,375 US dollars, was the most affordable studied international market.
If you are interested in what homes sell for in other regions, a few months ago Google added a real estate feature to its popular map application. Just visit maps.google.com and then in the map area, under the button labeled “More…” check the box labeled Real Estate. You will now be able to see listings of homes for sale right on the map. When playing with this feature bores you and you want to know more about how you can own a home like those you see, feel free to contact me.

TABLE 1
The top 10 most expensive and most affordable surveyed North American markets overall in 2009 are:
|
Rank |
Most Expensive |
2009 Avg. Sales Price In U.S. $ |
Most Affordable |
2009 Avg. Sales Price In U.S. $ |
|
|
1 |
La Jolla, Calif. |
$2,125,000 |
Grayling, Mich. |
$112,675 |
|
|
2 |
Beverly Hills, Calif. |
$1,981,750 |
Akron, Ohio |
$121,885 |
|
|
3 |
Greenwich, Conn. |
$1,519,250 |
Fayetteville, N.C. |
$130,875 |
|
|
4 |
Palo Alto, Calif. |
$1,489,726 |
Canton, Ohio |
$131,867 |
|
|
5 |
Santa Monica, Calif. |
$1,460,912 |
Detroit, Mich. |
$132,000 |
|
|
6 |
San Francisco, Calif. |
$1,363,250 |
Arlington, Texas |
$138,775 |
|
|
7 |
Boston, Mass. |
$1,337,578 |
Macon, Ga. |
$139,007 |
|
|
8 |
Newport Beach, Calif. |
$1,315,505 |
Eau Claire, Wis. |
$141,270 |
|
|
9 |
Palos Verdes, Calif. |
$1,237,041 |
Port Charlotte, Fla. |
$142,750 |
|
|
10 |
Vancouver, BC |
$1,174,241 |
Wichita, Kans. |
$144,625 |
TABLE 2
The most expensive and other more affordable markets (in CDN dollars) within selected provinces/territories in Canada are:
|
Province/Territory
|
Most Expensive
|
2009
Avg. Sales Price
|
|
More Affordable
|
2009
Avg. Sales Price
|
Variance
|
|
ALBERTA
|
Fort McMurray
|
$638,000
|
|
Edmonton
|
$432,250
|
$205,750
|
|
BRITISH COLUMBIA
|
Vancouver
|
$1,262,625
|
|
Burnaby
|
$657,250
|
$605,375
|
|
MANITOBA
|
Winnipeg
$390,368*
|
|||||
|
NEW BRUNSWICK
|
Moncton
$276,175 *
|
|||||
|
NEWFOUNDLAND
|
St.
John’s $348,750*
|
|||||
|
NOVA SCOTIA
|
Halifax
$277,302*
|
|||||
|
ONTARIO
|
Toronto
|
$824,347
|
|
Brantford
|
$239,750
|
$584,597
|
|
PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND
|
Charlottetown
$158,667 *
|
|||||
|
QUEBEC
|
Montreal
$469,250 *
|
|||||
|
SASKATCHEWAN
|
Saskatoon
$381,975*
|
|||||
|
YUKON
|
Whitehorse
$367,500*
|
|||||
TABLE 3
All surveyed Canadian markets 2009:
| Market | Province orTerritory |
2009 Avg. Sales Price in CDN $ |
2009 Avg. Sales Price in US $ |
Housing Index |
| Calgary | AB | $ 525,525 | $ 488,831 |
124 |
| Edmonton | AB | $ 432,250 | $ 401,993 |
102 |
| Fort McMurray | AB | $ 638,000 | $ 593,340 |
150 |
| Burnaby | BC | $ 657,250 | $ 611,243 |
155 |
| Kelowna | BC | $ 444,475 | $ 413,362 |
105 |
| Vancouver | BC | $ 1,262,625 | $ 1,174,241 |
298 |
| Victoria | BC | $ 663,000 | $ 616,590 |
156 |
| Winnipeg | MB | $ 390,368 | $ 363,042 |
92 |
| Moncton | NB | $ 276,175 | $ 256,843 |
65 |
| St. John’s | NF | $ 348,750 | $ 324,338 |
82 |
| Halifax | NS | $ 277,302 | $ 257,891 |
65 |
| Barrie | ON | $ 295,000 | $ 274,350 |
70 |
| Brantford | ON | $ 239,750 | $ 222,968 |
57 |
| Burlington | ON | $ 464,025 | $ 431,543 |
109 |
| Collingwood | ON | $ 290,000 | $ 269,700 |
68 |
| Greater Hamilton | ON | $ 346,375 | $ 322,129 |
82 |
| Huntsville | ON | $ 340,000 | $ 316,200 |
80 |
| Kitchener | ON | $ 350,000 | $ 325,500 |
83 |
| Lindsay | ON | $ 243,100 | $ 226,083 |
57 |
| London | ON | $ 363,500 | $ 338,055 |
86 |
| Mississauga | ON | $ 443,333 | $ 412,300 |
105 |
| Newmarket | ON | $ 385,000 | $ 358,050 |
91 |
| Oakville | ON | $ 469,500 | $ 436,682 |
111 |
| Oshawa | ON | $ 309,151 | $ 287,510 |
73 |
| Ottawa | ON | $ 360,650 | $ 335,405 |
85 |
| Port Perry | ON | $ 363,250 | $ 337,823 |
86 |
| Scarborough | ON | $ 481,750 | $ 448,028 |
114 |
| St. Catharines | ON | $ 333,333 | $ 310,000 |
79 |
| Toronto | ON | $ 824,347 | $ 766,643 |
194 |
| Waterloo | ON | $ 400,833 | $ 372,775 |
95 |
| Windsor | ON | $ 244,000 | $ 226,920 |
58 |
| Charlottetown | PE | $ 158,667 | $ 147,560 |
37 |
| Montreal | PQ | $ 469,250 | $ 436,403 |
111 |
| Saskatoon | SK | $ 381,975 | $ 355,237 |
90 |
| Whitehorse | YT | $ 367,500 | $ 341,775 |
87 |
TABLE 4
All surveyed international markets 2009:
| Country | Market |
2009 Avg. Sales Price in U.S. $ |
| ARUBA | Aruba |
$ 314,000 |
| AUSTRALIA | Brisbane |
$ 217,071 |
| BAHAMAS | Nassau |
$ 458,906 |
| BELIZE | San Pedro |
$ 244,300 |
| BERMUDA | Hamilton |
$ 1,348,813 |
| CAYMAN ISLANDS | Cayman Islands |
$ 526,250 |
| CHINA | Shanghai |
$ 1,386,750 |
| Chongqing |
$ 340,776 |
|
| COLOMBIA | Pereira |
$ 151,884 |
| Bogotá |
$ 182,926 |
|
| Cartagena |
$ 454,102 |
|
| COSTA RICA | Escazu |
$ 293,750 |
| Heredia |
$ 265,000 |
|
| Jaco Beach |
$ 385,500 |
|
| San Jose |
$ 269,500 |
|
| ECUADOR | Guayaquil |
$ 101,250 |
| Samborondon |
$ 154,250 |
|
| Salinas |
$ 69,375 |
|
| EGYPT | Cairo |
$ 273,393 |
| 6th October |
$ 859,625 |
|
| GUATEMALA | Guatemala City> |
$ 207,175 |
| HONDURAS | Roatan |
$ 299,500 |
| San Pedro |
$ 220,000 |
|
| Tegucigalpa |
$ 228,166 |
|
| INDONESIA | Bandung |
$ 112,367 |
| South Jakarta |
$ 494,252 |
|
| Tangerang |
$ 146,551 |
|
| IRELAND | Cork |
$ 534,360 |
| Dublin |
$ 1,127,843 |
|
| Galway |
$ 746,874 |
|
| ITALY | Florence |
$ 1,612,224 |
| Rome |
$ 1,261,740 |
|
| Milan |
$ 1,636,758 |
|
| LEBANON | Beirut |
$ 512,000 |
| MEXICO | Mexico City |
$ 207,020 |
| Monterrey |
$ 188,435 |
|
| NICARAGUA | Granada |
$ 239,750 |
| Managua |
$ 221,000 |
|
| PANAMA | Panama City |
$ 239,750 |
| ROMANIA | Ploiesti |
$ 402,778 |
| Brasov |
$ 300,764 |
|
| Bucharest |
$ 1,371,528 |
|
| SINGAPORE | Singapore |
$ 1,898,500 |
| ST. CROIX | Christiansted |
$ 602,500 |
| TURKEY | Istanbul |
$ 669,000 |
| Ankara |
$ 351,000 |
|
| Gaziantep |
$ 173,500 |
|
| Izmir |
$ 315,000 |
|
| TURKS AND CAICOS | Providenciales |
$ 872,225 |
| UNITED ARAB EMIRATES | Dubai |
$ 1,077,703 |
| VENEZUELA | Caracas |
$ 165,615 |
| Maracaibo |
$ 118,461 |
|
| Porlamar |
$ 151,653 |
|
| VIETNAM | Ho Chi Min City Dist 1 |
$ 341,099 |
| Hanoi |
$ 166,470 |
|
| DaNang |
$ 172,900 |

does this take into account the sharp decline in prices we have experienced in florida?
Its great to see that you quote prices on a specific type of house, and not an average home, very smart.
I believe house prices all over the world will stabilize. rich nations the price will fall, poor nations the price will rise
Its interesting that everything is expressed in U.S. Dollars. With the fall of the currency, it could make house prices look like they are rising, when actually they are falling, or inflate any rise that they do have.
That’s a lot of information to absorb. Great overview. I would like to see some data on historical house prices, in the past 25 years that would be really interesting to see.
the type of house you selected really isn’t the most important indicator for the economy. people who would purchase this type of homewould be financially well off and be insulated from troughs in the business cycle. so I a measure such as yours wouldn’t tell the whole story. if you select the prices of a first time buyers home the data would be more impressive. you would see when couples are forced out of the market.
Good post, some fascinating details. Do you think different houses increase in value at different rates? What type of house holds its value better?
I would like to thank you for the endeavors you have made in publishing these articles. I am a new real estate agent and I’m trying to broaden my knowledge of real estate property. I think I’ll be coming back to your website for quite awhile